Critical analysis/evaluation of my ident

I think the Ident that my group spoke about was the best. The reason why I think it was the best is because it wasn't just edited footage like the other ident I saw but instead it was creative and appealed to I think both males and females. The other ident I saw had lanterns being let off and nothing else really happened except the logo appearing before the end.

The animation my group spoke about was colourful and had animations that were fun to look at. Also the loge was animated to make it seem like something was passing through it which would help people remember it and also it helps establish the channel.